/leftypol/ - Leftist Politically Incorrect

"I ain’t driving twenty minutes to riot"

catalog
Mode: Reply
Name
E-mail
Subject
Message

Max message length: 8192

Files

Max file size: 20.00 MB

Max files: 3

Password

(used to delete files and postings)

Misc

Remember to follow the rules


/leftypol/ is a non-sectarian board for leftist discussion. Join the Matrix: https://matrix.to/#/+leftychat:matrix.org Visit the Booru: https://lefty.booru.org/

Anonymous 09/16/2020 (Wed) 07:46:33 No. 872632
Marx was the worst thing that happened to the left. We got literal slave societies instead of freedom and equality. Proudhons philosophy was the natural path towards communism after the french revolution.
How come?
>>872632 >Marx was the worst thing that happened to the left. Not really. Not even a Marxist, you faggots need to get over it. >We got literal slave societies instead of freedom and equality. Woah, gargantuan hyperbole even for height of Bolshevik oppression.
>Scientific socialism was the worst thing that happened to the left. Cringe and idealistpilled
Honestly, even as a "tankie" I'd say there are at least a dozen better anarchists you could have picked my dude. Proudhon got his shit so stomped by Marx it's hard to imagine anyone taking him seriously.
imagine what a sour loser you'd have to be to think this
>>872655 >Proudhon got his shit so stomped by Marx it's hard to imagine anyone taking him seriously. If someone never reads the criticism it's not that hard to imagine
Marx unironically was the worst thing that happened to the left, socialism was already on it's way after a few attempts and then Marx comes over and completely destroys an already stable system because he thinks his is better and then it's all downhill from there.
>>872662 >socialism was already on it's way Source?
>>872663 Wow you seriously haven't heard of the like dozens of "utopian" attempts at communism that had already happened by the time Marx came about?
>>872662 >Marx unironically was the worst thing that happened to the left Yeah you already said that in OP. >socialism was already on it's way after a few attempts This must be a bait.
>>872665 >imagine putting utopian in scarequotes
>>872668 >Anyone who agree's with OP is OP.
>>872668 Oh, you mean on it's way out the door. Gotcha.
>>872671 Ok so you're retard #2, big difference. You happy?
More is better. Marx & Engels collected works is ~35.000 pages total. Proudhon's life work is like ~2800 pages total. In terms of penises even if we halve M&E to 17.500 pages each, they had six times larger penises than Proudhon's tiny weeny little penis. How pathetic is the Proudhonist? Just point out his tiny penis and laugh in his face.
>>872665 So why didn't those attempts work while Marx-derived attempts did?
>>872684 brevity is the heart and soul of wit
>>872712 longevity is the heart and soul of dick
(25.51 KB 474x474 oof.jpg)
>>872714 >>872712 spicy shit
(26.36 KB 680x382 bastiat.jpg)
This dude BTFO Proudhon as well, poor guy can't catch a break.
no joke id shoot you for saying something retarded
>>872725 that's my attitude towards parenting as well
(610.73 KB 705x701 26236.png)
>>872719 >Proudhon famously lost his temper and declared to Bastiat: "Your intelligence is asleep, or rather it has never been awake. You are a man for whom logic does not exist. You do not hear anything, you do not understand anything. You are without philosophy, without science, without humanity. Your ability to reason, like your ability to pay attention and make comparisons is zero. Scientifically, Mr. Bastiat, you are a dead man".
>>872740 I mean i like Proudhon a lot and Bastiat and his ilk are cancer upon this world but this is not a good look. Dude was not a good debater.
>>872742 He was even worse philosopher.
>>872742 I mean...
>>872662 >>872665 Hmm, yes; if only America had a few more communes.
>>872632 >t. never read a book in his life
>>872632 even polyps make better b8 thread
>>872662 This. Marx was a glowie wrecker confirmed.
>>872632 This is the worst tread. Blaming other ideas for the failure of yours is intellectual infantilism.
>>872632 >Proudhons philosophy was the natural path towards communism you.. you do know he was a anti communist right? did you actually read his book? he was moving away from communism, not towards it
(292.82 KB 478x600 thelastthingaliberalsees.png)
>>872632 >Marx was the worst thing that happened to the left Jesus fucking Christ
>>872892 NOOOOOOOOOOO FACKU U DONOT UNDRSTND IT WAS (((BOLSHEVIK))) TEY STABED US IN TEH BACK
BTFO OP, turn thread in a theory discoussion

Delete
Report

no cookies?